I am a very visual person so I really enjoyed being able to watch the movie after reading the story. The issue I ran into was that I made an image of what I pictured the story to look like and I'm the move that's not quite how it played out. That always messes with my mind because I had a set image of it being one way and then it wasn't. If I had to choose one, I would prefer the movie. Only because I am such a visual person.
Don't get me wrong the story was good and it really makes you think, but I feel like you can understand the premise more when it was in the form of a film. Then again, I like movies because they only require a short amount of time and you get the whole story in that period. I’m lazy, so naturally, 2 hours of my time versus days tends to win me over. But as I’ve said, I’m trying to learn to love to read.
The additions I really enjoyed in the movie consisted of the ship and the reasoning behind Ian and Louise’s split. I feel like the ship really gave it that spectacular, incredible and unbelievable feeling that they were feeling in the movie when they saw it. It seemed to make the arrival itself a much bigger deal. I liked having a reason for Ian’s leaving because I think that is a major point in which you gain audience. You pull on their heartstrings. Along with Ian’s reason, having Hannah die at a much younger age also plays with people’s emotions. It really hits people hard watching a younger kid die rather than someone in their mid-twenties, so that was a good move on the screenwriters part.
Overall I think the story and the movie are both really well done and pull strong meaning. I liked the movie particularly due to the visuals. But I really enjoyed the format in the story and the “aha!” moment you have when you reach the end.